ANALYSIS-Asia coal traders risk over exposure on freight
Mon Nov 16, 2009 5:52pm IST
* Pacific coal trade 400 mln T/yr freight unhedged
* Indian traders may go bust due to poor risk management
* FFA market difficult for Indian players
By Jonathan Saul and Jackie Cowhig
LONDON, Nov 16 (Reuters) - Indian and Chinese coal traders face big losses if they fail to ramp up their use of derivative instruments to hedge a growing shipping freight exposure.
Indian traders who have not hedged either coal or freight costs are likely to fail to honour contracts, creating a domino effect of losses for their suppliers, said traders and producers who declined to be named.
This will result in a rash of disputes and lawsuits, they said, as has happened several times during the past few years.
Freight rates have remained erratic in recent months partly due to bursts of coal and iron ore buying activity by China and depressed demand for raw materials due to the economic downturn.
"If you have volatility in the freight market that has repercussions further down on the supply chain," Nikos Nomikos, reader in shipping risk management with London's Cass Business School, said.
Coal prices have also risen to a 12-month high this month due to strong demand from China and India.
For a graphic click on: here
Indian coal traders, who supply almost all the 20 million tonnes of South African coal imported annually into the country, are currently losing up to $10 a tonne by not hedging coal linked to the benchmark API4 physical price index. [ID:nLC437191]
Traders say importers have also not hedged their coal freight, with many companies facing massive losses and closure.
"We have lost in a month what we made in a year," an Indian trader said, declining to be named.
Some Indian traders say they may push counterparties to re-negotiate coal contracts at lower fixed prices to mitigate losses.
FFA MARKET
The 400 million tonne Asian physical coal trade is double that of the Atlantic market where traders hedge every tonne. Only a small part of coal price risk in Asia is hedged using swaps with even less done via freight forward agreements (FFAs).
FFAs allow a buyer to take a position over where freight rates will stand at a point in the future and are the commonly used instrument to hedge freight risks.
Most FFA contracts are settled against the Baltic Exchange's physical indices. For a graphic click on: here
"Any serious coal market player who isn't hedging his freight either through contracts or through taking in tonnage or through the freight derivatives market would seem to be running a significant and unnecessary risk," Baltic Exchange chief executive Jeremy Penn told Reuters.
Indian traders said they find FFAs costly and not entirely appropriate to their needs.
"The FFA market is not popular with the Indian market," another Indian coal trader said. "FFAs are difficult to use and expensive."
FFA shipping routes do not include the routes most used by Indian players to a variety of Indian ports from South Africa's Richards Bay. This means several FFA routes are needed to hedge.
Clive Murray, chief executive of London Commodity Brokers (LCB), said FFA market players were reluctant to accept Indian counterparties, making clearing more necessary than ever to reduce risk.
"The FFA market has a long way to go yet before it will be able to accept Indian exposure. Ship owners will take new names among the Chinese iron ore or coal buyers on a physical basis, but they won't do FFAs," he said.
CHINESE RISK
LCB has set up freight broking and iron ore broking divisions focused on the Indian and Chinese markets and has been trying to persuade players to use derivatives and options.
"There are more Chinese companies using freight derivatives than Indian coal traders," Murray said.
China became a net coal importer for the first time in 2009. [ID:nSHA260316]
Murray said exchange controls in China and India have made it difficult to use derivatives.
"The authorities in these countries need to have it proved to them that the use of derivatives is purely for hedging and not for speculating, which makes it complicated," he said.
Others especially in China, South Korea and Taiwan could choose to buy ships as a means of hedging their risk.
"We are starting to see cargo interests and utilities buying ships at the moment and they may be looking to cover their freight costs a bit more which is a form of hedging," Will Fray, shipping analyst with London-based consultants Maritime Strategies International, said. "We expect to see more of that."
RUMUS TRADING SAHAM HARIAN, sejatinya ANDA BACA dah
Arsip Blog
-
▼
2009
(338)
-
▼
November
(183)
- BUMI di atas 2500, yummy ... 301109
- royalti dan aktivitas NNT menuju taon2 mendebarkan
- sinetron badut: sesuai kontrak yang dibuat bersama...
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (11)... BURUAN
- RUMOUR OF THE DAY TODAY: google menyembah bumi ......
- rekomendasi analis pro, makin optimis ... 291109
- bumi sang pemilik 99% Multi Capital
- bumi resmi BERUTANG LAGI, dengan KOCEK LUMAYAN : 2...
- sinetron badut: sesuai kontrak yang dibuat bersama...
- investor BUMI GA KAPOK juga ... 281109
- bolak balik, bumi atawa dmb atawa multi capital BA...
- bumi optimis, the bakries jual right issues, inves...
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (10)
- bumi SAHAM RAJA TARIK DANA, saham sejuta TANGISAN ...
- bumi SEMAKIN RENTA, cic LOM BERPERAN (2)
- bumi PASTI CARI JALAN lagi dah ... 261109
- bumi dan asienk antara cinta dan benci ... 251109
- gara2 bertahan keras, bumi seret ihsg ... 251109
- bumi3526 ... wow : 251109
- lubang bumi tertutup ... for the moment : 251109
- bumi maseh lah dilirik ... 251109
- ati2 biaya transportasi batu item MENGGELEMBUNG
- isu YANG SENGAJA menghambat ... atawa menambat : 2...
- NNT uda lega ... katanya : 251109
- analis pro YAKIN atas nasib bumi pasca sinetron ba...
- ANALIS PRO jadi BLOON di depan nasib BUMI...(6)
- bumi SEMAKIN NGUTANG, semakin dijauhi ... 241109
- analis pro MULAI buy on weakness bumi ... 241109
- ekspansi bumi di tanah Mauritania ... 241109
- Herald maseh ditindaklanjuti bumi seh (2) ... 241109
- sinetron badut: sesuai kontrak yang dibuat bersama...
- sinetron badut: sesuai kontrak yang dibuat bersama...
- operatorship @ NNT
- sinetron badut: hepi juga dah AKHIRNYA ... 241109
- bumi emang SELALU PUNYA MIMPI ... 241109
- memang utang itu SPESIALISASI bumi ... 231109
- siapa penipu siapa yang mengakali ...
- sinetron badut: naluri SAPU BERSIH sang bumi
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (10)
- depkominfo BLOCKS all access from Indonesia to blo...
- lautan elektron itu NIKMAT bwat bumi ... 221109
- rumor repo LAGE @ bumi : sinetron badut ... 221109
- FT.com @ bumi 2009 ...
- Ba3 cukup bwat BUMI4000 ... semoga : 221109
- sinetron badut: bumi disalip, NGEGAP DONK ... 211109
- sinetron badut: happy ending donk ...
- pekan NYAMAN bumi
- sinetron badut: jejak rekam sejarah ringkas akuisi...
- sinetron badut: bener khan BADUT beneran ...
- diocehin, diomelin, disindir, BUMI MELENGGANG LEMP...
- sinetron badut: ayo BURUAN BUGIL ... tukh(2) : 201109
- sinetron badut: bumi melenggang lenggok dah ...
- sinetron badut: melenggang tak terhalang, bumi @ N...
- ANALIS PRO jadi BLOON di depan nasib BUMI...(5)
- badut LICIK, investor manut PICIK ... 201109
- bumi ngutang, itu MAH BIASA AJA dah ... 201109
- bumi emang BADUT LICIK : sinetron badut
- e-trading : sinetron badut SEKALI BADUT TETAP BADUT
- sinetron badut: eksekutif @ nnt ...(8)..more quest...
- sinetron badut: lha kok baru tau seh ...
- sinetron badut: yang bayar MDB kok ....
- dibuang broker asienk ... sedap : 191109
- ANALIS PRO jadi YAKIN di depan nasib BUMI...(2)
- analis pro YAKIN atas nasib bumi pasca sinetron ba...
- sinetron badut: sesuai kontrak yang dibuat bersama...
- sang capres MENGGORENG mateng bumi dan saudara2nya...
- ANALIS PRO jadi BLOON di depan nasib BUMI...(7)
- breaking news: sinetron badut: eksekutif @ NNT... ...
- sinetron badut: ayo BURUAN BUGIL ... tukh : 191109
- sinetron badut: DITUNJUK, itu kata yang PALING DIT...
- sinetron badut: kalo bole 100% SAHAM NNT ... WHY NOT
- sinetron badut: THE SHOW MUST GO ON... forever (2)
- sinetron badut: jatuh ke tangan dah, tukh durian r...
- sinetron badut: bumi melenggang lempeng dah
- sinetron badut: eksekutif @ nnt ...(8)..bakrie's v...
- ANALIS PRO: 301209 BUMI @3500...(5)
- bumi semakin MENDAKI untuk MENGGAPAI CITA2 sebagai...
- sesi 01 181109, saat bumi terendam BANJIR SAHAM UN...
- sinetron badut: yang hepi yang dapat duwit yang te...
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (12).. transp...
- sinetron badut: eksekutif @ nnt ...(8)..FORCED alt...
- ANALIS PRO jadi BLOON di depan nasib BUMI...(5)
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (11).. transp...
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (10)
- sinetron badut: eksekutif @ nnt ...(7)..FORCED BUYING
- rumor e-trading: NEW PARTNER @ bumi
- sinetron badut: antara 37,5 dan 50, ada yang jatuh...
- sinetron badut: telmi TAPI BACA AJA dah ...
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (9)
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (8)
- sinetron badut: win-win solution
- sinetron badut: BAYAR TUNAI, beneran (7)
- bandar bermain, investor KEGELIAN donk
- kalo lage mood, VIVA THE BAKRIES n bumi ...161109
- sinetron badut: pisah jalan itu BIASA ...barengan ...
- sinetron badut: eksekutif @ nnt ...(7)...badut bis...
- mulai trading JANGKA MENENGAH lage bwat bumi ...
- sinetron badut: UUD juga alasannya ... 131109
- sinetron badut: THE SHOW MUST GO ON... forever
- sinetron badut: namanya SINETRON BADUT, pasti beca...
-
▼
November
(183)
Mau Liat Maenan Saham2 gw Hari Ini :
SILAKAN klik LINK/TAUT ke BLOG2 gw YANG PENTING
- 3 HUKUM LABA maen saham
- uji NIAT investasi saham
- saham PGAS dan MAPI bo
- ANALISIS TEKNIKAL SAHAM BUMI harian
- Ekonomi Investasi Saham
- ORDER TRANSAKSI SAHAM BUMI HARI INI
- Antm, saham tambang EMAS
- PETA BLOG gw TERINCI, lebih jelas
- REKSA DANA, Investasi Tahan Krisis
- SERBA SERBI Investasi
- EKONOMI GLOBAL
- EKONOMI, dasar semua aktivitas HARIAN
- BBRI & Bnii, Saham Perbankan Indonesia
- Trub, Saham Batubara #5 Indonesia
- Indy, Saham Batu Bara #3 Indonesia
- Elsa, Saham Pengelolaan Minyak Indonesia
- Adro, Saham Batubara #2 Indonesia
- THE BAKRIES, Saham Sejuta Umat
- Maen Saham Sehari-hari
Langganan:
Posting Komentar (Atom)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar